We are an independent show guide. Resale ticket prices may be above face value.

The Reviews Are In For The Who's Tommy

Author DanielDaniel, April 19th, 2024

The Who's Tommy Gets the Thumbs Up from the Critics!

The reviews are rolling in for the revival of The Who's seminal rock opera Tommy'. Pete Townsend's swirling, kaleidoscopic score punctuates the fantastical tale of the titular character Tommy (played by Ali Louis Bourzgui), who descends into a catatonic state when he witnesses the murder of his mother's lover at the hands of his father. Despite being deaf, blind, and dumb, Tommy discovers he has a prodigious talent for pinball, marking him for worldwide fame and glory. A surprising celebration of the triumph of the human spirit over adversity, this classic production has earned its place in musical theatre history.

See what the critics had to say about Des McAnuff's (Jersey Boys, Big River) current revival debuting last week at the Nederlander Theatre below.

The Reviews

Timeout
"The show works, and its epic choral finale somehow feels genuinely rousing and healing. As musical theater, Tommy is limited. On its own terms, it's often sensational."

Vulture
"With Tommy, if the dissonance is sometimes distancing, it's also fascinating. Though I spent long stretches of the show intrigued and amused rather than earnestly rocking out, I was never not entertained. I had plenty of questions, but I also had a damn good time."

Theatrely: 
"Truth be told, I was not expecting to be as bowled over by this story, or this revival, as I was. But there's no arguing with talent, and with so much prowess on and off the stage, Tommy is an electric paean to rock immortality, and talent wherever one can find it."

Theatremania
"This new version adds another layer, exploring how our overreliance on technology can turn us into mindless sheep. It had me from start to finish, and it's an amazing journey I'd love to take again."

Entertainment Weekly
"In 1975, Tommy was adapted into a deliciously delirious film that featured the tagline, "Your senses will never be the same." Now, The Who's Tommy carries that torch forward in its own radical, one-of-a-kind adventure that truly has to be seen to be believed. See it, feel it you won't forget it."

New York Post:
 "The quaking revival of Pete Townshend's seminal rock opera, which opened Thursday night at the Nederlander Theater after nearly three decades away, really is an espresso martini of a show after a chamomile-tea season of musicals."

Wall Street Journal: 
"A big blast of boomer pleasure has arrived on Broadway at the Nederlander Theatre, where the thunderous and thoroughly intoxicating revival of "The Who's Tommy" has opened, giving a seismic jolt to the mostly lusterless musical season."

Chicago Tribune
"Now, though, the world has spun forward enough times to meet "Tommy" where it always lived, meaning its psychologically oriented story of delayed self-actualization due to childhood trauma, and its withering parody of abusive authority figures and celebrity worship."

New York Theatre Guide
"The great news is that what precedes and follows this moment also stirs and tickles the senses. That's the way this rock opera rolls, as it spins the story of a boy so deeply damaged by life first by his parents and later by his abusive uncle and creepy cousin that he nearly shuts down completely."

NEWS, TICKETS, THEATRE & MORE

"Broadway and show news straight to your inbox!"

MORE reviews

Review Roundup: The Roommate

Review Roundup: The Roommate

Daniel, September 16th, 2024
Last week, three-time Tony winner Patti LuPone, and Mia Farrow, who has been nominated for seven Golden Globes, shared the stage in the new Broadway production of Jen Silverman's 2015 play The Roommate'. The production will continue for a...
Read more
The Reviews For Once Upon a Mattress Are In!

The Reviews For Once Upon a Mattress Are In!

Kevin, August 13th, 2024
The beloved musical comedy made its tickling debut in 1959 and hasn't been seen on Broadway since 1996. On August 12 the show debuted at 37 Arts Theatre led by Two-time Tony winner Sutton Foster in the role of Princess Winnifred the Woebego...
Read more
The Reviews For Oh, Mary! Are In!

The Reviews For Oh, Mary! Are In!

Kevin, July 15th, 2024
Featuring Cole Escola in the role of a downtrodden Mary Todd Lincoln during the tense weeks before Abraham Lincoln's assassination, Oh, Mary! at the Lyceum Theatre is a one-act play that explores Mary's unfulfilled longings, struggles with...
Read more
The Reviews for Death Becomes Her Are In!

The Reviews for Death Becomes Her Are In!

Daniel, May 30th, 2024
The pre-broadway production of Death Becomes Her officially opened last weekend at Chicago's Cadillac Palace Theatre ahead of an already announced Broadway transfer. Starring Megan Hilty (Wicked), Jennifer Simard (Company), Christopher Sieb...
Read more
The Reviews For Illinoise Are In!

The Reviews For Illinoise Are In!

Daniel, April 30th, 2024
After an incredible off-Broadway run, the Sufjan Stevens-inspired musical finally opened on Broadway on April 24 at the St James Theatre. The show, which originated at Chicago's Shakespeare Theatre, offers a genre-defying coming-of-age stor...
Read more
Check Out The Reviews For Mary Jane!

Check Out The Reviews For Mary Jane!

Kevin, April 26th, 2024
Every publication has fallen head over heels for Mary Jane at Manhattan Theatre Club. So, what's the secret? Well, it stars Rachel McAdams and is penned by Amy Herzog......
Read more
From Paper Mill Playhouse to Broadway old sport, what did the critics think of The Great Gatsby?

From Paper Mill Playhouse to Broadway old sport, what did the critics think of The Great Gatsby?

Kitty, April 26th, 2024
Starring Jeremy Jordan and Eva Noblezada, the roaring twenties are in full swing for this production of The Great Gatsby. Adapted from F. Scott Fitzgerald's novella, published nearly 100 years ago, this re-imagining from the Paper Mill......
Read more