It's Mysteriously Good Pizza

Adapted from the 1988 movie of the same name, this adaptation from Sandy Rustin comes to the Paper Mill Playhouse in January 2025 in a new production directed by Casey Hushion, Relive the fun of the film and prepare yourself to jam out to the tunes of eighties legends like Cyndi Lauper and Starship - it's the best pizza you'll ever have!

What Is Mystic Pizza About?

Everybody loves rom-coms, pizza, and the classic underdog story. Mystic Pizza delivers a steaming hot pie of the three as it follows sisters Kat, Daisy and Jojo as they navigate their way through life and love from the pizza restaurant they all work at.