A modern Broadway classic, Jersey Boys ushered in a new era of Jukebox musicals but few of the shows that followed could match its gritty story, cool characters and dazzling songbook. It tells the story of Frankie Valli and the Four Seasons, four working-class guys from the wrong side of the tracks who went on to dominate the American charts in the 1950s and 60s.

The world premiere of the new musical Take the Lead is coming to the Paper Mill Playhouse in the spring of 2025. Based on the 2006 movie of the same name, which was based on the real-life of dance instructor Pierre Dulaine, the play takes you through New York's legendary ballroom scene and the place that Dulaine had in its mainstream uprising. Tony Award-nominated Christopher Gattelli is set to direct and will co-choreograph with & Juliet's Jennifer Wever and Maria Torres. Sure to have you dancing and singing in your seats, you don't want to miss Take the Lead!

The uplifting story and beloved songs of Bing Crosby's film White Christmas have been enjoyed by families for generations and this year you can catch this delightful musical adaptation at the Paper Mill Playhouse! Two former servicemen and best friends travel up and down the country with their two-man entertainment act, when out of the blue one Christmas, their old general calls them in desperate need. With two feisty sisters helping them out, can these guys save a Christmas pageant from disaster?

Adapted from the 1988 movie of the same name, this adaptation from Sandy Rustin comes to the Paper Mill Playhouse in January 2025 in a new production directed by Casey Hushion, Relive the fun of the film and prepare yourself to jam out to the tunes of eighties legends like Cyndi Lauper and Starship - it's the best pizza you'll ever have!

Join Ariel and friends under the sea in this musical version of one of Disney's most beloved movies from the Paper Mill Playhouse! Based on the fairytale by Hans Christian Anderson, The Little Mermaid is the story of Ariel, the princess of the underwater mermaid kingdom, who dreams of a life above the waves. Featuring all the classic Howard Ashman and Glen Slater songs from the movie ('Kiss the Girl,' 'Under the Sea'), The Little Mermaid is a surefire family hit!